Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

You may be adopting, or aiming to, one of the previous patterns.

Before moving into the actual implementation, we need to decide which workflow we'll use: do we want to use Xray/Jira as the master for writing the declarative specification (i.e. the Gherkin based Scenarios), or do we want to manage those outside using some editor and store them in Git, for example?



Info
titleLearn more

Please see Testing in BDD with Gherkin based frameworks (e.g. Cucumber) for an overview of the possible workflows.

The place that you'll use to edit the Cucumber Scenarios will affect your workflow. There are teams that prefer to edit Cucumber Scenarios in Jira using Xray, while there others that prefer to edit them by writing the .feature files by hand using some IDE.

...

Code Block
languagejava
titlesrc/main/java/com/xray/tutorials/Calculator.java
collapsetrue
package com.xray.tutorials;

public class Calculator
{
// Square function
public static int Square(int num)
{
    return num*num;
}
// Add two integers and returns the sum
public static int Add(int num1, int num2 )
{
    return num1 + num2;
}
// Add two integers and returns the sum
public static double Add(double num1, double num2 )
{
    return num1 + num2;
}
// Multiply two integers and retuns the result
public static int Multiply(int num1, int num2 )
{
    if ((num1==1) || (num2==1)) {
        return 0;
    } else {
        return num1 * num2;
    }
}



public static int Divide(int num1, int num2 )
{
    return num1 / num2;
}

// Subtracts small number from big number
public static int Subtract(int num1, int num2 )
{
    if ( num1 > num2 )
    {
    return num1 - num2;
    }
    return num2 - num1;
    }
}

Using Jira and Xray as master

This section assumes using Xray as master, i.e. the place that you'll be using to edit the specifications (e.g. the scenarios that are part of .feature files).

The overall flow would be something like this, assuming Git as the source code versioning system:

  1. define the story (skip if you already have it)
  2. create Scenario/Scenario Outline as a Test in Jira; usually, it would be linked to an existing "requirement"/Story (i.e. created from the respective issue screen)
  3. implement the code related to Gherkin statements/steps and store it in Git, for example. To start, and during development, you may need to generate/export the .feature file to your local environment
  4. commit previous code to Git
  5. checkout the code from Git
  6. generate .feature files based on the specification made in Jira
  7. run the tests in the CI
  8. obtain the report in Cucumber JSON format
  9. import the results back to Jira


Note that steps (5-9) performed by the CI tool are all automated, obviously.

To generate .feature file(s) based on Scenarios defined in Jira (i.e. Cucumber Tests and Preconditions), we can do it directly from Jira, by the REST API or using a CI tool; we'll see that ahead in more detail.


Example



All starts with a user story or some sort of “requirement” that you wish to validate. This is materialized as a Jira issue and identified by the corresponding issue key (e.g. CALC-7931).

Image Modified

We can promptly check that it is “UNCOVERED” (i.e. that it has no tests covering it, no matter their type/approach).


In this case, we'll create a Cucumber Test, of Cucumber Type "Scenario".

We can fill out the Gherkin statements immediately on the Jira issue create dialog or we can create the Test issue first and fill out the details on the next screen, from within the Test issue. In the latter case, we can take advantage of the built-in Gherkin editor which provides auto-complete of Gherkin steps.

Image Modified


After the Test is created it will impact the coverage of related "requirement", if any.

The coverage and the test results can be tracked in the "requirement" side (e.g. user story). In this case, you may see that coverage changed from being UNCOVERED to NOTRUN (i.e. covered and with at least one test not run).

Additional tests could be created, eventually linked to the same Story or linked to another one (e.g. multiplication).

...

The related statement's code is managed outside of Jira and stored in Git, for example.

The tests related code is stored under src/test directory, which itself contains several other directories. In this case, they're organized as follows:

...

  • java/

...

  • calculator: step implementation files

...

  • and test runner class.
    • The steps "glue-code" is defined in

...

    • the StepDefinitions class.
Code Block
languagejava
titlesrc/test/java/calculator/StepDefinitions.java
collapsetrue
package calculator;

import io.cucumber.java.en.Given;
import io.cucumber.java.en.Then;
import io.cucumber.java.en.When;
import com.xray.tutorials.Calculator;

import static org.junit.Assert.*;

public class StepDefinitions {
    private Integer int1;
    private Integer int2;
    private Integer result;


    @Given("I have entered {int} into the calculator")
    public void i_have_entered_into_the_calculator(Integer int1) {
        this.int2 = this.int1;
        this.int1 = int1;
    }
    
    
    @When("I press add")
    public void i_press_add() {
        this.result =  Calculator.Add(this.int1, this.int2);
    }

    @When("I press multiply")
    public void i_press_multiply() {
        this.result =  Calculator.Multiply(this.int1, this.int2);
    }


    @Then("the result should be {int} on the screen")
    public void the_result_should_be_on_the_screen(Integer int1) {
        // Write code here that turns the phrase above into concrete actions
        assertEquals((Integer)(this.int1 + this.int2), this.result);
    }
    

}

You can then export the specification of the test to a Cucumber .feature file via the REST API, or the Export to Cucumber UI action from within the Test/Test Execution issue or even based on an existing saved filter. A plugin for your CI tool of choice can be used to ease this task.

So, you can either:

...

  • Image Removed

...

Code Block
languagejava
titlesrc/test/java/calculator/RunCucumberTest.java
collapsetrue
package calculator;

import io.cucumber.junit.Cucumber;
import io.cucumber.junit.CucumberOptions;
import org.junit.runner.RunWith;

@RunWith(Cucumber.class)
@CucumberOptions(plugin = {"pretty"})
public class RunCucumberTest {

}


You can then export the specification of the test to a Cucumber .feature file via the REST API, or the Export to Cucumber UI action from within the Test/Test Execution issue or even based on an existing saved filter. As source, you can identify Test, Test Set, Test Execution, Test Plan or "requirement" issues. A plugin for your CI tool of choice can be used to ease this task.

So, you can either:

  • use one of the available CI/CD plugins (e.g. see details of Integration with Jenkins)
    • Image Added
  • or even use the UI (e.g. from a Test issue)
    • Image Added
  • use the REST API directly (more info here)
    • Code Block
      languagebash
      #!/bin/bash
       
      rm -f features/*.feature
      curl -u admin:admin  "http://jiraserver.example.com/rest/raven/1.0/export/test?keys=CALC-7931;CALC-7935&fz=true" -o features.zip
      unzip -o features.zip  -d features

We will export the features to a new directory named features/ on the root folder of your Java project (we'll need to tell Maven to use this folder).


After being exported, the created .feature(s) will contain references to the Test issue key, eventually prefixed (e.g. "TEST_") depending on an Xray global setting, and the covered "requirement" issue key,  if that's the case. The naming of these files is detailed in Export Cucumber Features.

Code Block
titlefeatures/1_CALC-7931.feature
collapsetrue
@REQ_CALC-7931
Feature: As a user, I can calculate the sum of two numbers
	#As a user, I can calculate the sum of two numbers

	#Tests As a user, I can calculate the sum of two numbers
	@TEST_CALC-7934
	Scenario Outline: sum of two positive numbers
		Given I have entered <input_1> into the calculator
		And I have entered <input_2> into the calculator
		When I press <button>
		Then the result should be <output> on the screen
		
		  Examples:
		    | input_1 | input_2 | button | output |
		    | 20      | 30      | add    | 50     |
		    | 2       | 5       | add    | 7      |
		    | 0       | 40      | add    | 40     |
		    | 4       | 50      | add    | 54     |
		    | 5       | 50      | add    | 55     |	

	
	@TEST_CALC-7933
	Scenario: negative integer adition
		Given I have entered -1 into the calculator
		And I have entered 2 into the calculator
		When I press add
		Then the result should be 1 on the screen	

	#Tests As a user, I can calculate the sum of two numbers
	@TEST_CALC-7932
	Scenario: simple integer addition
		Given I have entered 1 into the calculator
		And I have entered 2 into the calculator
		When I press add
		Then the result should be 3 on the screen
Code Block
titlefeatures/2_CALC-7935.feature
collapsetrue
@REQ_CALC-7935
Feature: As a user, I can multiply two numbers
	#As a user, I can multiply two numbers

	#simple integer multiplication
	@TEST_CALC-7936
	Scenario: simple integer multiplication
		Given I have entered 3 into the calculator
		And I have entered 0 into the calculator
		When I press multiply
		Then the result should be 0 on the screen



To run the tests and produce Cucumber JSON reports(s), we can run Maven and specify that we want a report in Cucumber JSON format and that it should process .features from the features/ directory.


Code Block
languagebash
mvn compile test -Dcucumber.plugin="json:report.json" -Dcucumber.features="features/"


This will produce one Cucumber JSON report with all results.

After running the tests, results can be imported to Xray via the REST API, or the Import Execution Results action within an existing Test Execution, or by using one of the available CI/CD plugins (e.g. see an example of Integration with Jenkins).

Code Block
languagebash
titleexample of a Bash script to import results using the standard Cucumber endpoint
collapsetrue
curl -H "Content-Type: application/json" -X POST -u admin:admin --data @"report.json" http://jiraserver.example.com/rest/raven/1.0/import/execution/cucumber

Image Added


Info
titleWhich Cucumber endpoint to use?

To import results, you can use two different endpoints/"formats" (endpoints described in Import Execution Results - REST):

  1. the "standard cucumber" endpoint
  2. the "multipart cucumber" endpoint

The standard cucumber endpoint (i.e. /import/execution/cucumber) is simpler but more restrictive: you cannot specify values for custom fields on the Test Execution that will be created.  This endpoint creates new Test Execution issues unless the Feature contains a tag having an issue key of an existing Test Execution.

The multipart cucumber endpoint will allow you to customize fields (e.g. Fix Version, Test Plan), if you wish to do so, on the Test Execution that will be created. Note that this endpoint always creates new Test Executions (as of Xray v4.2).


In sum, if you want to customize the Fix Version, Test Plan and/or Test Environment of the Test Execution issue that will be created, you'll have to use the "multipart cucumber" endpoint.


A new Test Execution will be created (unless you originally exported the Scenarios/Scenario Outlines from a Test Execution).

Image Added


One of the tests fails (on purpose).

The execution screen details of the Test Run will provide overall status information and Gherkin statement-level results, therefore we can use it to analyze the failing test.

Image Added

Results, including for each example on Scenario Outline, can be expanded to see all Gherkin statements.

Image Added  Image Added


Note: in this case, the bug was added on purpose on the Calculator class. 


Code Block
languagejava
titlebuggy Multiply() method in Calculator.java
collapsetrue
public static int Multiply(int num1, int num2 )
{
    if ((num1==1) || (num2==1)) {
        return 0;
    } else {
        return num1 * num2;
    }
}
Info
titleScreenshots and other attachments

If available, it is possible to see also attached screenshot(s). For this, you'll need to use Cucumber's API and do it in a After hook, for example (using scenario.embed()).

Image Added




Results are reflected on the covered items (e.g. Story issues) and can be seen in ther issue screen.

Coverage now shows that the addition related user story (e.g. CALC-7931) is OK based on the latest testing results; on the other hand, the multiplication related user story (CALC-7935) is NOK since it has one test currently failing.

Image Added  Image Added


If we fix the code on the Calculator class, run the tests and import results, coverage for the multiplication related user story will be shown as OK.

Code Block
languagejava
titlefix of Multiply() method in Calculator.java
collapsetrue
public static int Multiply(int num1, int num2 )
{
	return num1 * num2;
}

Image Added

...

#!/bin/bash
 
rm -f features/*.feature
curl -u admin:admin  "http://jiraserver.example.com/rest/raven/1.0/export/test?keys=CALC-7905;CALC-7906&fz=true" -o features.zip
unzip -o features.zip  -d features

...

Description

We will use the code from the Github repository "cucumber-java-skeleton", with slight changes in order to make the dummy Test pass.

...

The execution screen details will provide information on the test run result.

...

.


  


Info

The icon represents the evidences ("embeddings") for each Hook, Background and Steps.

...